Criteria Ratings Points
Content
Relevance
28 to >24 pts
Advanced
Demonstrates
clear content
mastery,
addresses all
assignment
requirements, and
in-depth
thought/reflection.
24 to >19 pts
Proficient
Demonstrates an
attempt at content
mastery, addresses
several assignment
requirements, and
demonstrates an
attempt at in-depth
thought/reflection.
19 to >0 pts
Developing
Loosely demonstrates
an attempt at content
mastery, all
assignment
requirements are not
met, and there is
weak evidence of
in-depth
thought/reflection.
0 pts
Not Present
No attempt at
content mastery, all
assignment
requirements are not
met, and there is no
evidence of in-depth
thought/reflection.
28 pts
Content
Analysis
28 to >24 pts
Advanced
Demonstrates a
clear
understanding of
self and others.
Clear
understanding of
course concept.
24 to >19 pts
Proficient
Demonstrates a weak
understanding of self
and others. Weak
understanding of
course concepts.
19 to >0 pts
Developing
Demonstrates a
vague understanding
of self and others.
Vague understanding
of course concepts.
0 pts
Not Present
No evidence of
understanding of self
or others. No
understanding of
course concepts.
28 pts
Content
Self-Reflection
28 to >24 pts
Advanced
Demonstrates
clear questioning
of biases,
stereotypes,
and/or
assumptions.
Attempt of new
modes of thinking
are evident.
24 to >19 pts
Proficient
Demonstrates vague
questioning of biases,
stereotypes, and/or
assumptions. Weak
attempt of new modes
of thinking are evident.
19 to >0 pts
Developing
Demonstrates poor
questioning of own
biases, new modes of
thinking not evident.
0 pts
Not Present
No evidence of
questioning own
biases, new modes
of thinking not
evident.
28 pts
Sports Chapel Strategy Grading Rubric | SMGT402_D01_202320
Criteria Ratings Points
Structure
Clarity
12 to >10 pts
Advanced
Focus is clear,
good paragraph
structure, varied
use of diction and
word choice,
assertions are
supported, correct
spelling,
punctuation,
capitalization,
correct
noun/pronoun
agreement.
10 to >7 pts
Proficient
Minor lapses in focus.
Minor errors in
paragraph structure,
diction, word choices
lack variety, assertions
are not clearly
supported, three or four
errors in spelling,
punctuation, and
capitalization, correct
noun/pronoun
agreement.
7 to >0 pts
Developing
Focus of the paper is
not clear. Weak
paragraph structure,
repetitive use of
diction and word
choice, assertions are
not supported, 5
errors in spelling,
punctuation, and
capitalization,
incorrect
noun/pronoun
agreement.
0 pts
Not Present
Focus of the paper is
not clear. Weak
paragraph structure,
repetitive use of
diction and word
choice, assertions
are not supported, 5
errors in spelling,
punctuation, and
capitalization,
incorrect
noun/pronoun.
12 pts
Structure APA
Format
12 to >10 pts
Advanced
Correct use of
APA format,
correct font/style,
in-text citations,
reference page
correctly
formatted, paper
written in objective
third person.
10 to >7 pts
Proficient
Three to four errors in
correct use of APA
format, correct
font/style, missing or
errors in in-text
citations, two or three
errors on the reference
page, paper written in
objective third person.
7 to >0 pts
Developing
Five errors in use of
APA format, incorrect
font/style, in-text
citations incorrectly
formatted or lacking,
four or more errors on
reference page, paper
is not written in
objective third person.
0 pts
Not Present
Six or more errors in
use of APA format,
incorrect font/style,
in-text citations
incorrectly formatted
or lacking, Six or
more errors on
reference page,
paper is not written
in objective third
person.
12 pts
Structure
Assignment
Parameters
12 to >10 pts
Advanced
Paper addresses
the assignment,
correct number of
pages, pagination,
correct number of
scholarly sources
for academic
support.
10 to >7 pts
Proficient
Paper is one page
short of requirement,
no pagination, one
source shy of
requirement for
scholarly sources for
academic support.
7 to >0 pts
Developing
Two pages short of
requirement, no
pagination, two
sources shy of the
requirement for
scholarly sources for
academic support.
0 pts
Not Present
Three or more pages
short of requirement,
no pagination, three
sources shy of the
requirement for
scholarly sources for
academic support.
12 pts
Total Points: 120
Sports Chapel Strategy Grading Rubric | SMGT402_D01_202320